Selvester v. United States

by Edward Douglass White

United States Supreme Court

170 U.S. 262

Selvester  v.  United States

The plaintiff in error was indicted for alleged violations of section 5457 of the Revised Statutes. The indictment contained four counts. The first charged the unlawful possession of two counterfeit half dollars; the second, an illegal passing and uttering of two such pieces; the third, an unlawful passing and uttering of three pieces of like nature; and the fourth, the counterfeiting of five like coins. The case came on for trial, and after the jury had retired they returned into court, and stated that, while they agreed as to the first three counts, they could not do so as to the fourth; and the court was asked if a verdict to that effect could be lawfully rendered. They were instructed that it could be. The district attorney thereupon asked leave to enter a nolle prosequi as to the fourth count, but upon objection by the accused the motion was withdrawn, and the jury rendered the following verdict: 'We, the jury, find James Selvester, the prisoner at the bar, guilty on the first, second, and third counts of the indictment, and disagree on the fourth count of the indictment.'

Despite objection and exception by the accused, the court received this verdict, and discharged the jury.

By motions in arrest of judgment, to set aside the verdict, and for a new trial, the defendant asserted that the verdict was a nullity, because 'insufficient, incomplete, and uncertain.' Exceptions were duly noted to the overruling of these several motions, and, the court having imposed sentence, a writ of error was allowed.

Arthur English, for plaintiff in error.

Asst. Atty. Gen. Boyd. for the United States.

Mr. Justice WHITE after stating the facts in the foregoing language, delivered the opinion of the court.

Notes