Metaphysics (Ross, 1908)/Book 9

←

Book 8

Metaphysics, Book IX (Theta) (350 B.C.E.)
by Aristotle, translated by W. D. Ross and J. A. Smith

Book 9

Book 10

→

(1908) Annotations pertaining to Greek translation not included.

Aristotle4170962Metaphysics, Book IX (Theta) — Book 9350 B.C.E.W. D. Ross and J. A. Smith

Layout 2

Chapter 1

We have treated of that which is primarily and to which all the other categories of being are referred — i.e. of substance. For it is in virtue of the concept of substance that the others also are said to be — quantity and quality and the like; for all will be found to involve the concept of substance, as we said in the first part of our work.^[1] And since 'being' is in one way divided into 'what', quality, and quantity, and is in another way distinguished in respect of potency and complete reality, and of function, let us discuss potency and complete reality. First let us explain potency in the strictest sense, which is, however, not the most useful^[2] for our present purpose. For potency and actuality extend further than the mere sphere of motion. But when we have spoken of this first kind, we shall in our discussions of actuality^[3] explain the other kinds of potency.

We have pointed out elsewhere^[4] that 'potency' and the word 'can' have several senses. Of these we may neglect all the potencies that are so called by an equivocation. For some are called so by analogy, as in geometry; and^[5] we say things can be or cannot be because in some definite way they are or are not.

But all potencies that conform to the same type are starting-points, and are called potencies in reference to one primary kind of potency, which is a starting-point of change in another thing or in the thing itself qua other. For one kind is a potency of being acted on, i.e. the principle in the very thing acted on, which makes it capable of being changed and acted on by another thing or by itself regarded as other; and another kind is a state of insusceptibility to change for the worse and to destruction by another thing or by the thing itself qua other, i.e. by a principle of change. In all these definitions is implied the formula of potency in the primary sense. — And again these so-called potencies are potencies either of acting merely or of being acted on, or of acting or being acted on well, so that even in the formulae of the latter the formulae of the prior kinds of potency are somehow implied.

Obviously, then, in a sense the potency of acting and of being acted on is one (for a thing may be 'capable' either because it can be acted on or because something else can be acted on by it), but in a sense the potencies are different. For the one is in the thing acted on; it is because it contains a certain motive principle, and because even the matter is a motive principle, that the thing acted on is acted on, one thing by one, another by another; for that which is oily is inflammable, and that which yields in a particular way can be crushed;^[6] and similarly in all other cases. But the other potency is in the agent, e.g. heat and the art of building are present, one in that which can produce heat and the other in the man who can build. And so in so far as a thing is an organic unity, it cannot be acted on by itself; for it is one and not two different things. And want of potency, or powerlessness, is the privation which is contrary to potency of this sort, so that every potency belongs to the same subject and refers to the same process as a corresponding want of potency. Privation has several senses; for it means (1) that which has not a certain quality and (2) that which might naturally have it but has not it, either (a) in general or (b) when it might naturally have it, and either (i) in some particular way, e.g. when it completely fails to have it, or (ii) when it in any degree fails to have it. And in certain cases if things which naturally have a quality lose it by violence, we say they suffer privation.

↑ Cf. Γ. 1003^a 33 and Ζ. 1.
↑ 1045^b 36 read χρησιμωτάτη.
↑ Cf. Θ. 1048^a 27.
↑ Cf. Δ. 12.
↑ 1046^a 7 read colon after γεωμετρία. Cf. Δ. 1019^b 22-33 and note.
↑ i.e. the event would not happen if the passive factor were different. What is oily cannot necessarily be crushed, nor what is yielding burnt.

[1] Cf. Γ. 1003^a 33 and Ζ. 1.

[2] 1045^b 36 read χρησιμωτάτη.

[3] Cf. Θ. 1048^a 27.

[4] Cf. Δ. 12.

[5] 1046^a 7 read colon after γεωμετρία. Cf. Δ. 1019^b 22-33 and note.

[6] .e. the event would not happen if the passive factor were different. What is oily cannot necessarily be crushed, nor what is yielding burnt.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

Metaphysics (Ross, 1908)/Book 9

Navigation menu

Search