Jump to content

Page:A critical and exegetical commentary on Genesis (1910).djvu/456

From Wikisource
This page needs to be proofread.

Abraham dwelt.—If Ḥavîlah has been rightly located on p. 202 above, J fixes the eastern limit of the Ishmaelites in the neighbourhood of the Ǧōf es-Sirhān, while the western limit is the frontier of Egypt (on Shûr, see on 167). This description is, of course, inapplicable to P's Ishmaelites; but it agrees sufficiently with the statement of E (2121) that their home was the wilderness of Paran; and it includes Lahai-roi, which was presumably an Ishmaelite sanctuary. Since a reference to Assyria is here out of place, the words (Symbol missingHebrew characters) must be either deleted as a gloss (We. Di. Mey. al.), or else read (Symbol missingHebrew characters); (Symbol missingHebrew characters) being the hypothetical N Arabian tribe supposed to be mentioned in 253 (so Gu.; cf. Homm. AHT, 240 f.; Kön. Fünf Landsch. 11 ff.), a view for which there is very little justification.—18b is an adaptation of 1612b, but throws no light on that difficult sentence. Perhaps the best commentary is Ju. 712, where again the verb (Symbol missingHebrew characters) has the sense of 'settle' (= (Symbol missingHebrew characters) in 1612). Hommel's restoration (Symbol missingHebrew characters), 'in front of Kelaḥ' (a secondary gloss on (Symbol missingHebrew characters)), is a brilliant example of misplaced ingenuity.