Page:Early Greek philosophy by John Burnet, 3rd edition, 1920.djvu/286

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
272
EARLY GREEK PHILOSOPHY

As to the moon's light and the cause of eclipses, it was natural that Anaxagoras should be credited at Athens with these discoveries. On the other hand, it seems very unlikely that they were made by a believer in a flat earth, and there is sufficient evidence that they are really Pythagorean.[1]

136.Biology. "There is a portion of everything in everything except Nous, and there are some things in which there is Nous also" (fr. 11). In these words Anaxagoras laid down the distinction between animate and inanimate things. He tells us that it is the same Nous that "has power over," that is, sets in motion, all things that have life, both the greater and the smaller (fr. 12). The Nous in living creatures is the same in all (fr. 12), and from this it followed that the different grades of intelligence we observe in the animal and vegetable worlds depend entirely on the structure of the body. The Nous was the same, but it had more opportunities in one body than another. Man was the wisest of animals, not because he had a better sort of Nous, but because he had hands.[2] This is in accordance with the previous development of thought upon the subject. Parmenides, in his Second Part (fr. 16), had already made the thought of men depend on the constitution of their limbs.

As all Nous is the same, we are not surprised to find that plants were regarded as living creatures. If we may trust the pseudo-Aristotelian Treatise on Plants[3] so far, Anaxagoras argued that they must feel pleasure and pain in connexion with their growth and with the fall of their leaves. Plutarch says[4] that he called plants "animals fixed in the earth."

Both plants and animals originated in the first instance from the πανσπερμία. Plants arose when the seeds of

  1. See p. 177, n. 1.
  2. Arist. De part. an. Δ. 10. 687 a 7 (R. P. 160 b).
  3. [Arist.] De Plant. A, 1. 815 a 15 (R. P. 160).
  4. Plut. Q.N. 1 (R. P. 160), ζῷον . . . ἐγγεῖον.