Page:Joseph Story, Commentaries on the Constitution of the United States (1st ed, 1833, vol III).djvu/21

From Wikisource
Jump to navigation Jump to search
This page has been proofread, but needs to be validated.
CH. XVI.]
POWERS OF CONGRESS—BANKRUPTCY.
13

ment. It did not release or discharge the debt, or exempt the future acquisitions of the debtor from execution for the debt. The English statute, commonly called the "Lords' Act," went no farther, than to discharge the debtor's person. And it may be laid down, as the law of Germany, France, Holland, Scotland, and England, that their insolvent laws are not more extensive in their operation, than the cessio bonorum of the civil law. In some parts of Germany, we are informed by Huberus and Heineccius, a cessio bonorum does not even work a discharge of the debtor's person, and much less of his future effects.[1] But with a view to the advancement of commerce, and the benefit of creditors, the systems, now commonly known by the name of "bankrupt laws," were introduced; and allowed a proceeding to be had at the instance of the creditors against an unwilling debtor, when he did not choose to yield up his property; or, as it is phrased in our law, bankrupt laws were originally proceedings in invitum. In the English system the bankrupt laws are limited to persons, who are traders, or connected with matters of trade and commerce, as such persons are peculiarly liable to accidental losses, and to an inability of paying their debts without any fault of their own.[2] But this is a mere matter of policy, and by no means enters into the nature of such laws. There is nothing in the nature, or reason of such laws to prevent their being applied to any other class of unfortunate and meritorious debtors.[3]


  1. 1 Kent's Comm. Lect. 19, p. 336; 1 Domat, B. 4, tit. 5, § 1, 2.
  2. 2 Black. Comm. 473, 474.
  3. See Debate on the Bankr. Bill in the House of Representatives, Feb. 1818, 4 Elliot's Debates, 282 to 284.—Perhaps as satisfactory a description of a bankrupt law, as can be framed, is, that it is a law for the