THE BELLEVUE HOSPITAL CASE
Witness (hesitating). "I made two affidavits. I believe that is in the second affidavit."
Counsel. "Answer my questions, Mr. Minnock. Is there any doubt that you had forgotten it when you made the first affidavit to the World?"
Witness. "I had forgotten it."
Counsel (abruptly). "When did you recollect?"
Witness. "I recollected it when I made the second affidavit before the coroner."
Counsel. "And when did you make that?"
Witness. "It was a few days afterward, probably the next day or two."
Counsel (looking among his papers, and again walking up to the witness). "Please take the coroner's affidavit and point out to the jury where there is a word about a sheet having been used to strangle this man."
Witness (refusing paper). "Well, it may not be there."
Counsel. "Is it there?"
Witness (still refusing paper). "I don't know."
Counsel. "Read it, read it carefully."
Witness (reading). "I don't see anything about it."
Counsel. "Had you forgotten it at that time as well?"
Witness (in confusion). "I certainly must have."
Counsel. "Do you want this jury to believe that, having witnessed this horrible scene which you have described, you immediately forgot it, and on two different occasions when you were narrating under oath what took place in that hospital, you forgot to mention it?"
235
