Later Magazines 111 Southern Quarterly Review, Oct., 1854. Northern Periodicals versus the South. Spectator, 31 Aug., 1889. American Magazines. Northup, Clark Sutherland. The Periodicals. In : A Manual of American Lit- erature, edited by Theodore Stanton. 1909. Tassin, Algernon. The Magazine in America. 1916. (Also serially in The Book- man, Vols. XL, XLI, XLIl). Wilson, James Grant (ed.). Memorial History of the City of New York, from its first settlement to the year 1892. 1893. [Newspapers and Magazines, by William L. Stone: magazines. Vol. iv, p. 159.] Winsor, Justin (ed.) . The Memorial History of Boston, including Suffolk County, Mass., 1630-1880. Boston, i88i. [The Press and Literature of the Last Hundred Years, by Charles A. Cummings, Vol. iii, p. 617.] Young, John Russell (ed.). Memorial History of the City of Philadelphia, from its first settlement to the Year 1895. Philadelphia, 1898. [Weekly News- papers and the Magazines, Vol. 11, p. 268.] The Reviews Hageman, John Frelinghuysen. History of Princeton and its Institutions. 2d ed. 2 vols. Philadelphia, 1879. [Princeton Review, Vol. 11, p. 63.] Historical Magazine, Vol. iii, p. 343 (1859). Contributors to the North American Review from its Commencement to the Present Time. Lowell, James Russell. Letters, edited by Charles Eliot Norton. 3 vols. Boston, 1904. [North American Review.] Scudder, Horace E. James Russell Lowell : a Biography. 2 vols. Boston, 1901. [North American Review.] North American Review, Vol. c, p. 315 (1865). The Semi-centenary of the North American Review. Vol. cci (1915). Many articles relating directly and indirectly to the cen- tenary of the Review. Among those having relation to the last half -century see From Madison to Wilson, p. i; The North American Review (by J. H. Ward), p. 123; Part of Which I Was (W. D. Howells), p. 135] This Review: a Reminiscence (H. C. Lodge), p. 749. Atlantic Monthly {Note. Many books of personal reminiscences and the biographies of most of the New England men of letters who flourished in the last half of the nineteenth century abound in references to the Atlantic Monthly. Only a few of the most important are listed here.] Atlantic Monthly, Mar., 1902. Mr. Scudder and the Atlantic. Nov., 1907. Fiftieth Anniversary Number. Contains several articles in commemoration of the fiftieth anniversary of the magazine, chief among which are: The Launching of the Magazine (C. E. Norton), p. 579; An Early Contributor's Recollections (J. T. Trowbridge), p. 582; Recollections of an Atlantic Editor- ship (W. D. Howells), p. 594; Atlantic Dinners and Diners (Arthur Oilman), p. 646; The Editor who Was Never the Editor (Bliss Perry), p. 658; Contrib- utor's Club, p. 715. Emerson, Edward Waldo. The Early Years of the Saturday Club. 1855- 1870. Boston, 1918. Ralph Waldo. Journal. Vol. ix, p. 117. Boston, 1913. Greenslet, Ferris. Life of Thomas Bailey Aldrich. Boston, 1908. Howe, M. A. DeWolfe. The Atlantic Monthly and Its Makers. Boston, 1919.