Quinn v. United States (349 U.S. 155)/Concurrence Harlan

by by John Marshall Harlan

United States Supreme Court

349 U.S. 155

Quinn  v.  United States (349 U.S. 155)

 Argued: April 4, 5, 1955. --- Decided: May 23, 1955

Mr. Justice HARLAN, concurring.

I agree with the result reached by the Court in this case. But I must dissent from the holding made in part II of the majority opinion. The reasons for my position are stated in part II of my dissenting opinion in the Emspak case, 349 U.S. 190, 75 S.Ct. 687. I consider those reasons equally applicable to what is shown by the record in this case.

Mr. Justice REED, dissenting.

Notes