South Boston Iron Company v. United States/Opinion of the Court

by Morrison Waite

United States Supreme Court

118 U.S. 37

South Boston Iron Company  v.  United States

 Argued: April 19, 1886. ---

In Clark v. U.S., 95 U.S. 539, it was decided that, to bind the United States, contracts by the navy department must be in writing, and signed by the contracting parties. Such, in the opinion of the court, was the effect of the act of June 2, 1862, (12 St. 411, c. 93,) now in force as sections 3744-3747, 512-515, Rev. St. An effort has been made in this case to show a contract in writing, but we agree entirely with the court of claims that the papers relied on for that purpose are nothing more in law or in fact than the preliminary memoranda made by the parties for use in preparing a contract for execution in the form required by law. This was never done and therefore the United States never became bound. Within a very few days after the memoranda were made the whole matter was abandoned by the department, and the iron company has neither performed any of the wrok which was referred to, nor has it ever been called on to do so.

The judgment is affirmed.

Notes