User:Peteforsyth/Portal:Marcus Whitman
Dr. Marcus Whitman was an important figure in the history of the Pacific Northwest region of North America, as much for his alleged deeds as for anything he actually did.
Dr. Whitman and his wife, Narcissa Prentiss Whitman, traveled to the Oregon Country in the 1830s and, under the auspices of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions (ABCFM), established a Presbyterian mission called Waiilatpu at the site of present-day Walla Walla, Washington.
By 1842, the ABCFM was increasingly questioning the mission's success, and Catholic missionaries were gaining traction where Protestants had fallen short. When the ABCFM ordered the closure of Waiilatpu, Dr. Whitman undertook a daring winter ride to the east coast, to appeal the decision. Having persuaded the ABCFM to permit the mission to continue, he returned with the migration of 1843, which brought an unprecedented 1,000 settlers to the region.
For many years, Whitman's colleagues and hagiographers claimed that he had "saved" Oregon to the United States, by persuading President Tyler and Secretary of State Webster to negotiate harder with the British for control of the region; in addition, he was credited with having rallied and lead the 1,000 settlers back to Oregon. Both claims were strongly contested, initially by the research of Oregon historian Frances Fuller Victor, with other historians validating her efforts in later years. In the meantime, the controversy was explored in multiple west coast periodicals over a span of more than two decades. Yale historian Edward Gaylord Bourne published research on the matter in 1901 which was considered by many to settle the matter of Whitman's intentions and role, but more recent scholarship still regards these questions as unresolved.
In 1847 Dr. Whitman, his wife, and about 12 others were savagely assassinated by the Indians their mission had aimed to convert, sparking the Cayuse War that would nearly eradicate the tribe from the region.
- Whitman: Letter to American Board (1843)
- Gray
- Spalding
41st U.S. Congress: Senate Executive Document No. 37:
- Letter from the Secretary of the Interior (Whitman Massacre) (1871)
- Letter from the Secretary of the Interior (Whitman Massacre)/American Congress vs. Protestantism in Oregon (1871)
In The Californian (1880s magazine):
- Clarke in How Dr. Whitman Saved Oregon in The Californian (1880)
- Victor in Did Dr. Whitman Save Oregon? in The Californian (1880)
- Eells: Marcus Whitman, M.D.: Proofs of his Work in Saving Oregon to the United States and in promoting the immigration of 1843 (transcription project) (1883, 42 pp)
- Victor in Oregonian Nov. 6, 1884 (transcription project)
- Evans: Whitman's Winter Ride, in the Oregonian, Dec. 25, 1884
- Ross, Eells, Gray: The Whitman Controversy (1885)
- Evans: Whitman's Winter Ride, in the Oregonian, Dec. 25, 1884
- Nixon: How Marcus Whitman saved Oregon (note many images) (1895)
- Victor: San Francisco Call/1895/How Oregon Was Saved (1895)
- H. S. Lyman in the Oregonian (review): (transcription project)
- S. L. B. Penrose in the Oregonian (1897) (external scan)
- Oregonian (unsigned editorial on 50th anniversary of assassination) (external scan) (1897)
- "Whitman Day" feature piece, Oregonian (1897) (external scan)
- Beadle: "The Story of Marcus Whitman" Refuted in The American Catholic Historical Researches (1899)
- Bourne: The American Historical Review/Volume 6/The Legend of Marcus Whitman (1901)
- critical response from Oregon pioneer Alanson Hinman in the Oregon Historical Quarterly, 1901.
- Bourne: Essays in Historical Criticism (1901)
- Marshall (in proceedings of AHA): (external scan)
- Marshall: A Scathing Review of Mowry's book (1902)
- Oregonian: Description of Marshall's review (1902)
- Marshall: History vs. the Whitman saved Oregon story (1904)
- Centennial in East Oregonian (1902)
- Eells: Marcus Whitman, Pathfinder and Patriot (transcription project) (1909) (note many images)
- Marshall: Acquisition of Oregon and the long suppressed evidence about Marcus Whitman Vol. 1 and Vol. 2 (1911)
- W. D. Lyman: The Columbia River (Part 1, chapters 6 and 7.
- John Fiske's Change of Attitude on the Whitman Legend in the Oregon Historical Quarterly, 1912
- New York Times, 1923: History and Legend condemns President Warren Harding for promulgating the Whitman Legend, declares that it has long since been debunked, credits several people including Fiske, Marshall as well as Frederick Van Voorhies Holman, Harvey Whitefield Scott
Bibliographies
[edit]- A Contribution toward a Bibliography of Marcus Whitman (transcription project)
- Seattle Public Library Reading List, 1905 - two pages of sources covering Marcus Whitman controversies