The Anatomy of Tobacco
the abstract idea of German pipes to be "An eternal not ourselves that makes for cloudiness." But, on the other hand, Stoschius will have it that men are not Irish navvies because they smoke short black pipes, but smoke short black pipes because they are Irish navvies, which being a knotty point I leave for the solution of my readers, and trust they may come to a satisfactory conclusion thereon.
Next cometh the question whether pipe⟨s⟩ can ever begin to be, or ever cease to exist. Now in the Organum Novissimum it is thus argued that pipes have no beginning:—"All matter has existed from eternity, all pipes are matter—ergo, all pipes have existed from eternity," which seems indeed to be a true and valid syllogism in Barbara. And foreseeing that some might object to the major premiss as contrary to religion, it has been put in this form:—Since matter first existed no matter has been destroyed; but pipes are matter, therefore, since matter first existed, no pipes have been destroyed—i. e., pipes have existed from the be-
130
